This newsletter was originally published in May 2023
In each issue, Bottle Bill Common Ground will explain a single principle or practice for a meaningful, modern DRS. We will cover topics such as ease of use for consumers, production standards for industry, and compliance and enforcement measures for government.
By following this roadmap, states can achieve major environmental and economic benefits
This issue of Bottle Bill Common Ground focuses on Principle #3 of the 10 high-performance principles for an effective deposit return system (DRS) – $0.10 Minimum deposit
Principle #2: $0.10 Minimum deposit
Motivate consumers to return containers by having a high-enough deposit, paired with easy access, to ensure higher levels of redemption.
-
High-performance principles to modernize Deposit Return Systems
Fact sheet introducing the key principals underpinning modern Deposit Return Systems in the United States.
The word “deposit” is literally at the heart of any bottle bill; a basic requirement is the collection of a monetary deposit on beverage containers (refillable or non-refillable) at the point of purchase. That deposit is refunded to the consumer when the empty container is returned to a redemption location for reuse and/or recycling. Let’s take a look at why a modernised DRS requires that we meaningfully consider the deposit.
Because the consumer has an economic incentive to recycle, DRSs result in beverage container recycling rates two to three times higher than the rates achieved by states or communities that rely only on curbside recycling programs, particularly if the deposit is set at an effective level.
If the deposit is set too low, consumers can feel “return fatigue.” Why spend time and energy returning a container when the financial reward on that effort is so low? In this day and age, a nickel no longer means that much. A dime deposit, however, tells a different story.
All research data on DRS in action shows that beverage container deposits should be set at no lower than $0.10.
- When Oregon increased its deposit on beverage containers from 5 to 10 cents in April 2017, the impact was immediate — only seven months later, by December 2017, the redemption rate jumped from 64% to 82%. In April 2023, Oregon’s rate was at 88.5%, the highest in the US.
- Michigan’s nearly 90% redemption rate (pre-COVID) is linked to its $0.10 deposit.
The chart below shows return rates in DRS jurisdictions by Minimum Deposit Amount (USD). One can see clearly that far lower rates of return in Canada and US states are linked to lower deposit rates. In states (e.g., Oregon and Michigan again) or countries (e.g., Germany and Norway) with deposits at 10-15 US cents, the return rates are consistently above 90%.
Click on this image to view a larger version
Experience in these jurisdictions has also shown that it is critical to build a mechanism within bottle bill legislation to adjust the value of the deposit if redemption rates fall, even when minimum redemption point requirements are met.
Reloop North America’s research on the impacts of DRS modernisation modelled a $0.10 minimum deposit collection rate in five Northeast states and found this impact:
Get the latest from Reloop
We’ll send occasional email updates with details of our work. You can unsubscribe from our emails at any time and we won’t pass on your information to anyone else.
Issue #2:
90% Collection Rate
Issue #4:
Inclusive Circular System
